June 30, 2004

  • A few minutes ago, while I was brewing coffee and thinking about
    blogging, I didn’t know if this would be a movie review, today’s
    journal entry (well, yesterday’s really, as it is 3:33AM right now), or
    a memoir segment.  I guess the only thing to do is to write it out
    and see how it comes out.  I may be able to fit some of all of
    those things in.  I guess a good place to start is where I left
    off last time.  There’s a comment on my earliest memory blog that I want to respond to:

    leafylady wrote:

    Your memory is
    sad.  I’m glad most children don’t remember the heartbreaking things
    our parents do.  I know I’ve done such things, though not that
    particular one.  What if my child remembered every “leave me alone”,
    every “no” to a snuggle?

    I suppose that means she was saddened by it.  The memory I hold in
    my mind is not sad.  I don’t feel sad when I think of it, and I
    certainly won’t accept responsibility for the judgement anyone else
    lays on my story.  The memory is just a memory.  Any
    emotion attached to it is in the mind of whomever is feeling that
    emotion.  The feelings that surround that memory for me are like
    an “AHA!” of understanding–so much of what came later makes sense in
    the light of that night.  I’m glad I remember.

    I have felt saddened sometimes by the thing that reportedly gladdens
    leafylady:  the fact that “most children” are so traumatized by
    the cognitive dissonance inherent in the abuse and neglect they receive
    at the hands of  their “loving” parents that they dissociate and
    block out the memories or deny the events.  I put “most” in quotes
    because I am not at all sure that most of us do not have unpleasant
    memories of parental misdeeds that we’d prefer not to recall. 

    The denial dance is one of the main rituals of this culture:  “You
    didn’t like that, eh?  Okay, just pretend it didn’t happen. 
    If you tell anyone I did it, I’ll say you’re lying, anyway.”  That
    few have the courage to face reality within themselves, and even fewer
    have enough courage to speak it out loud, tends in my weaker moments to
    sadden me.

    I do not suppose that hypothetical “what if” question was anything
    other than rhetorical.  Unless I miss my guess, I’m not supposed
    to answer it–so, I’ll just echo it:  “What IF your child
    remembers?”  I want mine to remember.  Remembering is
    healthy, and in people with unhealthy pasts it can be
    therapeutic.  We cannot process and transcend trauma that we do
    not remember.  I work at remembering, and to whatever extent I am
    successful, I profit by it.


    I’m watching the sky grow lighter.  An hour or two ago it was as
    dark as it gets this time of year, not dark but just twilight. 
    Each summer in recent years I’ve done at least one up-all-nighter and
    sometimes Doug has stayed up with me.  He’s in bed now, and it
    looks like this will be an all-nighter for me.  His sleep schedule
    had him in bed rather early Monday evening, he was up again in the wee-small hours
    of Tuesday soon after I’d gone to bed, and I kept him busy through most of
    Tuesday.

    Koji had an appointment with the vet for his annual health checkup and immunization boosters.  Taking him anywhere
    in the car is not something anyone would want to do alone, and Doug
    likes to get away from here when he gets a chance, anyway.  Our
    dog never wants the pack to be separated, so when one of us goes
    anywhere, he thinks we should all go.  That would be fine, except
    he’s the only member of this pack with the stamina to run for miles,
    and when we take him anywhere in the car he gets stress diarrhea. 
    The vet thinks it’s interesting that he never gets car sick, but always
    has to have a stop or two along the way to relieve the peristaltic
    pressure.

    He was sweet and funny at the vet’s.  We were early because I left
    home early enough to allow for stops along the way.  During our
    long wait, Doug and I took him outside once to offer him a drink of
    water, but he just whined and pulled back toward the clinic door. 
    He knew he was there for a purpose and he wasn’t going to leave without
    seeing the vet.  When we all got into the exam room together Koji
    trembled and cringed but made no move to bolt, nor displayed any
    hostility or aggression.  He’s a trouper, that dog. 

    He’s healthy, she said, but getting a little fat pad on his middle, so
    she wants us to get his weight down by about a pound and a half, to an
    even 60 lbs.  That seems an arbitrarily round number, and she gave
    us no clues on how to do it.  She also wants us to have him
    neutered, although she said that the testosterone he produces by virtue
    of being intact helps keep his weight down.  I’m getting cognitive
    dissonance here.  My menfolk are both aware that their own
    testosterone makes them vulnerable to similar prostate problems to
    those the vet warned us about for Koji, and neither of them wants to be
    neutered to prevent such problems.  I guess I’ll have to ask Koji
    how he feels about it.  He’s sleeping now.  We wore him out.

    After the vet visit, it was just a short trip to Felony Flats, so we
    dropped Koji with Greyfox while Doug and I had lunch and went
    shopping.  I introduced him to the taco bar at Yukon’s, then he
    led me to the bookstore.  He was delighted to find a whole section
    of manga, and bought three, each the first episode of its series. 
    I found a special sale on bargain books, bought two at big discounts
    and got a third free.  Two were recent novels by authors I
    like.  The real prize was The Notebooks of Leonardo da Vinci
    I can tell that having this book is going to be fun.  My mind lit
    up when I saw it there at under ten dollars, and I saw both Doug’s and
    Greyfox’s eyes light up when I showed it to them.

    While Doug and I were buying groceries I noticed that sugar was on sale
    at a good price, so I purchased some for the NA group.  I saw Doug
    look disbelievingly at the two bags as I put them in the cart, then
    look questioningly at me.  He knows the stuff is poison to me,
    because I remind him every time I see him indulging in it.  I’m
    sure I’d mentioned before that one
    of my service positions is to supply the drugs:  the coffee
    (caffeine is addictive), sugar (addictive), and creamer (containing
    casein, also addictive) for our little group in that “program of complete abstinence from all drugs.”

    Anyhow, since I had the sugar to drop off and it was near time for the
    Tuesday night meeting, we went out to Felony Flats and relieved Greyfox
    of Koji’s company to make it easier for him to close up his stand for
    the day, then Doug and Koji waited for me in the car while I attended
    the meeting.  After that, it was back to Greyfox’s cabin to pick
    up empty water jugs for me to fill on my way back in on Thursday, and a
    few other things he had for me.

    We stopped at the local general store before coming home, because Doug
    wanted to rent a video.  We ended up with a (sorta) western double
    feature:  Jackie Chan’s Shanghai Knights and Wyatt Earp with Kevin Costner.  He watched all of the Chan with me, and faded out in the middle of Earp.

    I remember the first time I heard Wyatt Earp’s name.  I thought
    the kids were saying “white urp” and since “urp” was a popular
    euphemism for vomitus, I couldn’t understand why the kids wanted to
    play white urp and I hadn’t a clue what would be involved in such a
    game.  I was a California kid newly arrived in Kansas.  It
    didn’t take those kids long to clue me in that the game was similar to
    the games of Cowboys and Indians I’d played on the Coast, and that
    White Urp was a local hero.

    Over time, I learned that it was Wyatt Earp, and learned some other
    associated names such as Dave Rudabaugh, Johnny Ringo, Bat Masterson,
    and Doc Holliday.  There in Kansas in the 1950s, the lines between
    the “good guys” and the “bad guys” were clear cut and plain.  I
    recall that in that first game of White Urp I was assigned to be Johnny
    Ringo, a bad guy.  *sigh*  Out west, I’d always been assigned
    to play an Indian, since I was a girl and most of my playmates were
    boys.  Actually, I had always sorta liked being an Indian, and
    Johnny Ringo had a cool name.  The only problem was that I’d
    always get shot, but I’d get some fun out of it by doing a dramatic
    death scene.

    To my great relief and increased viewing pleasure tonight, the movie
    was more true to life than most are, and so the characters were not so
    clearly delineated in black and white.  I suppose it’s
    understandable that those Kansas kids would see the Earp brothers as
    heroes, being descendants of settlers and sodbusters whose towns had
    been cleared of lawless drunken cowhands and trail riders by such rough
    and rowdy lawmen.  The museums I recall visiting in Wichita and
    Dodge City portrayed the Earps as heroes and displayed guns and other
    artifacts of theirs along with those such as Bat Masterson’s cane and
    Doc Holliday’s hip flask.

    It’s a different story in Tombstone, Arizona, where Doc and the Earps
    had to face a judge after the gunfight at the OK Corral, and where to
    this day Wyatt is considered by many to be a deranged spree killer who
    became unhinged and hunted down everyone who might possibly have been
    involved in his brother Morgan’s murder.  That story involves a
    lot of unsolved crimes, and much of it remains a mystery except to
    those who have made their minds up on one side or the other based more
    on where their loyalties lie than on the facts, because facts are in
    short supply and much dispute.

    I have always loved a good story, especially when the storyteller got
    it straight.  I have seen, heard and read many versions of the
    Earps’ story, most of which played fast and loose with those facts that
    are known and embroidered freely to fill in the gaps.  Most of the
    movie or novel versions of the gunfight in Tombstone have it fought in
    a corral, but it was on a streetcorner near the OK Livery Stable’s
    corral.  The re-enactors in Tombstone do a pretty good job of
    presenting it, complete with noise and gunsmoke, but completely without
    the fake blood that might make it more believable.  Some acting
    ability among the reenactors wouldn’t hurt, either.  The ones I’ve
    seen were just phoning in their parts.

    Often, time is condensed in those stories and Morgan is killed in the
    gunfight on October 26, 1881.  He really died about five months
    later, either shot while shooting pool in a billiards room or shot
    while on the boardwalk outside the billiards room and carried in and
    laid out on a pool table where he died.  That latter is what was
    reported in the Tombstone Epitaph
    at the time, and is the version reported currently on a plaque outside
    the building in question in Tombstone.   The former is the
    way the movie I saw tonight presented it, and the way it is told in
    several other accounts I’ve read.  Who knows?  The Epitaph, like the Weekly World News of today, said mostly what it’s editor wanted to say and occasionally threw in the true facts just to throw people off guard.

    Tombstone has many of those little plaques that say something like, “On
    this site, on October 26, 1881″ or “…on October 27, 1881,” etc., this
    or that happened.  One of my favorite such signs says, “On October
    26, 1881, nothing much happened on this site.”

    Despite a few real floaters that just didn’t fit the generally accepted
    facts, I liked the movie.  One aspect of it that continually
    distracted me from the story and detracted from my enjoyment probably
    wouldn’t bother most viewers.  They kept jumping around
    geographically.  One sweet love scene outside “Tombstone” was shot
    on the banks of Oak Creek in Sedona with Courthouse Rock in the
    background.  A chase and gunfight that was supposed to be between
    Tombstone and Bisbee was actually at Pine Flat between Sedona and
    Flagstaff.  That’s understandable, because Sedona is a much more
    pleasant area to be than down around Tombstone.  If I had a movie
    to make, I’d shoot it in Sedona, even if it was set on the Moon. 
    But in the next scene after that fight, they ride over a little hill
    and suddenly they’re in Utah.  It’s jolting.  That’s what I
    get for paying attention to geography and geology.  

    I guess this entry is long enough, now, and it is well and truly full
    daylight outside, or as light as it is going to get under this pall of
    smoke from the wildfires.  Tuesday’s Anchorage Daily News reported
    fifty-five separate fires in the state at press time.  During
    lunch at Yukon’s I caught a teaser for the TV news, which showed a
    street scene in Fairbanks, like pea soup fog, only brown.  Each
    time yesterday that the sun became visible through the clouds it was a
    dim red-orange disk in the sky.  The  smoke in the air even
    here at least a couple of hundred miles from the fires is making
    breathing more difficult and stinging my eyes and throat.

    I’m off to bed to read my new book.  Later, all.

Comments (7)

  • Yes, the memory evoked sadness in me, probably because I weaned my own daughter less than six months ago and I remember the mixed love/hate feelings about nursing as a mother. 

    No I don’t think I’d want children to forget the abuses that I think of as serious- physical or emotional, or the most emotional happy & sad times. 

    Is that part of what makes children resilient- their ability to forget and then to re-learn?  Babies that are neglected or abused early on can still recover and thrive in a better environment. 

  • Thank god, I’m getting better at chortle-stifling without hurting myself–”white urp,” indeed.  And neutered–okay, my testicles ARE mostly decorative, but still–I’m attached to them.

    And I have GOT to get cracking on the next Blogfodder blog.  Next rainy day fer shure.

  • yes to remembering, processing *and* transcending. you need them all i think.

  • I can relate to that “Aha” of comprehension. When my father died, my mom confessed that she never wanted children, and that made everything in my life finally make sense.

  • It’s true. I don’t remember very much from back when my dad would beat my mom and me, but if I try and think about it I can, and that’s not good. I’m glad I blocked that stuff.

  • Remind me never to watch a movie with you–haha! I went with my dad and brother to some budget theatre years ago to watch those volcano movies. Problem was, my dad is a geologist. I got an entire lesson on plate tectonics and the different forms of volcanoes outta that one.

    As for the remembering, I really wish I could remember some things, traumatic as they were. I’m missing years that I feel would make a lot of things clear to me. 

  • I forget to remember sometimes

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *