June 19, 2004
-
The definition of “insanity” is once again up for legal debate in Alaska.
Alaska law regarding the “insanity defense” is one of the strictest in the country.
“
So-called NGI pleas are very rare here because of Alaska’s extremely
limited definition of legal insanity. In a 1982 statute known as the
Meach law, the Legislature limited insanity to defendants who literally
do not know what they are doing: someone who thinks they are killing a
ghost instead of a real person, for instance. Or someone who thinks
they’re squeezing a lemon when they’re actually strangling a human
being.”Charles Meach, the man that law is named after, beat to death a toddler
on the day he was released from reform school in his youth. Then,
when he got onto the streets again after that, he killed his
parents. In 1982, he had gotten out yet again and that time he
killed four teenagers when they found him stealing tape cassettes from
their campsite in an Anchorage park.Somehow, that man’s story convinced our legislators that the part of
the law that allowed for a defense based on the defendant’s not knowing
that his act was wrong, was wrong. Personally, I think
there are several other conclusions to be drawn from the case that
might be more logical than that one, and a few other responses that
might be more rational in terms of protecting society from recidivists.But who am I to advise anyone on anything related to the subject of
sanity versus insanity? It’s all a game of semantics,
anyway. Legal insanity is not the same as the psychiatric
definition. Most shrinks I know try to avoid the word as too
vague and general. They differentiate between dementia,
psychosis, neurosis, and personality disorders. I understand the
differences, but few members of the general public do. To most
people crazy is nuts and it’s synonymous with insane and that’s
that. To me, people who believe that are crazy.My favorite among all the 12-step programs I’m familiar with is Double
Trouble in Recovery, the group for those of us who have been or are currently
under psychiatric care or on psychotropic or antipsychotic
medication. I like it because there is less denial and hypocrisy
in that group than in any of the others. And that’s as it should
be. Is that not what shrinks are for, to help us transcend such
craziness as hypocrisy and denial? The average person in this culture who has not had the
benefit of psychotherapy is clearly nuts.In DTR meetings, when we introduce ourselves (first name only in the
anyonymous tradition), where in AA we say “I’m an alcoholic,” and in NA
we say, “I’m an addict,” we use one or both of those terms
(“alcoholic/addicts” are common even in NA, less so in AA meetings
where in many groups there’s some resistance to even letting dope
fiends in) and add our psychiatric diagnoses. Greyfox, for
example, uses his narcissistic personality disorder as his ticket to
Double Trouble meetings.I say that I’m an addict (alcohol is a drug and we are addicts)
recovering from OCD (obsessive-compulsive disorder, but no one in DTR
needs to have stuff spelled out for them) and bipolar II (the type of
manic-depression that is hypomanic and mainly depressive). At my
first meeting I said that I have also been diagnosed as schizotypal,
and that I dispute that diagnosis. That got a laugh. There
are few of us who would dispute that most of us are often
misdiagnosed. Some crazy average normal people actually believe
that medicine (psychiatry is a medical specialty) is an exact science.I first brought that schizotypal shit up at the DT meeting to be
funny
and to strengthen my claim to belonging there. I love the
group. Now Greyfox, never one to shy away from stealing a good
line, has
started saying that same thing about a disputed diagnosis of
schizotypal personality
disorder. No shrink ever diagnosed either of us that way, but
when we take tests such as the one on 4degreez.com,
they say that we have mild-to-moderate schizotypal PD, because of our
shamanic work and psychic abilities. In the constrictive
little reality bubble inhabited by an average normal insane person,
that makes us crazy. Norms are statistical units and the
majority of people in this culture believe in things that are
irrational, imaginary and, frequently, absurd. It’s all maya, illusion, anyway.
Some shrinks, those with belief systems (BS,
or “reality bubbles”) in which there is no such thing as valid psychic
experiences and/or an alternate reality such as those in which shamans
work, might give Greyfox and me each a single checkmark on the DSM symptom list,
but it takes five or more to diagnose. I suppose that there are
many shrinks who would, because of their own narrow reality tunnels,
declare our past-life memories delusional and would, from their
superstitious fear and denial, say that the shared memories many of us
have are mass delusions. But since a few of the past-life
associates with whom I share some of those memories are now members of
the psych professions, I won’t condemn the whole profession for the
craziness of some of its members. It’s a crazy culture and it
takes a lot of courage to swim against the stream.Anyway, the case in which the insanity definition has just come up is
one of a woman who has admitted to shooting and killing her three
teenage sons. Police, lawyers and everyone concerned are very
close-mouthed about her motive. It is known that she told
arresting officers why she did it, but no one is talking. I
suspect that could be because it’s going to be a hot-button racial
issue, or it could be some bizarre insane delusion that police and
prosecutors fear could get her off. Photos in the first
news stories to come out about the crime show that she and her sons
were of different colors, and the mom is known to have been on some
kind of medication that one of her sons had told someone she’d stopped
taking.
Anchorage Daily News | Mom who says she shot sons is fit for trialHow to make a SuSu Ingredients:
5 parts intelligence
1 part brilliance
1 part egoMethod:
Blend at a low speed for 30 seconds. Add a little fitness if desired!From Go-Quiz.com
How to make a Kathy Ingredients:
3 parts pride
1 part self-sufficiency
5 parts empathyMethod:
Layer ingredientes in a shot glass. Add a little cocktail umbrella and a dash of fitnessAND *hehee*:
From Go-Quiz.com
You are very psychic.You are very likely to feel that you are psychic
and many other people around you may have even confirmed this belief.
If you’re not pursuing classes or learning more about developing your
skills, it’s only a matter of time before you embark on a new adventure
into the realm of the paranormal.
http://www.sixthsearch.com/rupsychic/index.asp
Comments (11)
yikes, that personality disorder test is scary.
Please keep us posted…I get more news and knowledge from reading you than from living…lol…hmmm says a lot for me…ok so I am a geek….maybe a bit delusional as well!
Hey thanks for writingi n my Xanga… well, i’ll be sure to type out my novel… thanks
anyway… yes, people always have to find an excuse for theyr short comings… and thats the story fo the world.. and its disgusting. I would hang myself if i were a lawyer… just knowing that i could lose to a defence like that you know? its disconcerting to the human race.. but then who are we trying to impress?? even so…. i dunno… its depressing ya?? well im gonan check out that personality disorder test… I’ll probably get Paranoia … cause ive gotten that twice on two different quizes … yes im lame.. all we all? .. seeya dear
-Xelias
hAHAHHAA! how funny is that?? You know how i said id get Paranoia… that was my HIGH … too funny…. TOO funny,,, i totally know my self… shit.. i sure hope so…
debating over the legal definition of insanity… i think that is insane
*agrees with m_loaf*
The government and law just can’t seem to leave things to the professionals.
I have wondered how many empaths and psychic’s would be categorized under a DSM differential! Food for thought there.
Heh m_loaf took my idea too.
Aww.. I knew that I would talk to you sooner or later. I was going to leave comment but I didnt know where to begin. You are right about waht u said on my xanga. YOU are the first to acutally mention it to me. I’m trying
hope to talk with you soon
peace love and eternal light
Thank you for your comment, I really appreciate it. : /
Bah…the human mind is a marvelous thing… so sad that peripheral perspective is a trademark. good thing for those of us that believe reality is actually subjective/non-existant.
Ps– you’ve had such a neat life. <3
The definition of insanity is insane…