July 15, 2003

  • Review:
    Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix


    My kid got me hooked on the Harry Potter books long before the first movie came out.  Jan Rowling is my hero, would be my role model if I could write fiction… maybe if I study her enough I can learn how.  I’ve gotten into verbal battles with people who claim she writes “children’s books.”  She writes books that are genre benders, books that satisfy readers of all ages. 


    I would have been disappointed if my all-time favorite character, Dobby the house-elf, had been left out of this book, but of course, I wasn’t disappointed.  Poor Dobby, with his butterbeer-addicted wife, forced by Hermione Granger’s well-meaning but misguided philanthropic efforts into doing all the cleaning by himself.  (How does one write a review without spoiling the fun for those who haven’t read the book yet?)


    This time, Dobby’s role is small compared to that of Kreacher, the aged and cranky house-elf of Sirius Black’s family.  How can I put this?  Kreacher is no Dobby; that’s for sure.  He is fiercely loyal to his now-dead former mistress, Sirius’s late mother.   There’s even a bit of lovable cuteness in the description of his pathetic little nesting area, if not in the elf himself or his bigotry and treachery.


    Some of our old favorite characters get a chance to display heroism this time around, notably Ron Weasley and Neville Longbottom.  I’ve always liked Neville (and it goes without saying, does it not, that I love the red-haired Weasleys?) and wished that he would get bigger parts.  This time, his part turned out to be all I could have wished for.  Likewise for George and Fred, Ron’s twin brothers.  For me, they provided more laughs in this book than any of the other characters, I think.



    Unless I just failed to notice her before, the girl pictured at left, Luna “Loony” Lovegood, is a new character this time.  She has personality, that girl, and provides some surprising insights for Harry, too.


    Other new characters showing up for the first time in Order of the Phoenix include Hagrid’s little brother Grawp, a despicable old witch named Professor Umbridge, and another, more likable, witch with whom, for some reason I find hard to articulate, I identified strongly.  I don’t really know what it is about Nymphadora Tonks that I like, but I really do like her.  Maybe it’s a fantasy thing… I’d like to be like her.  That WOULD be fun.


    Reading this book was fun.  As with all the rest of the series, it is well-plotted, with good character development.  From chapter to chapter through most of the book, I was looking forward to getting back to it each time I put it down.  Then, toward the end, I couldn’t put it down.  I stayed up long past my bedtime, turning page after page, speeding through the climax.  And that’s all I’m telling you about that.



    Just FYI, anyone who has been following my personal love story and who doesn’t sub to my darlin’ Greyfox, he has blogged today about some of the recent details of our story, from his angle.

Comments (7)

  • OH!  I so love the Potter series!  My kids have me hooked too!  I read all five in one week..lol.  I am a sap.. I cried through about 30 pages.  I had to stop and wipe tears from my eyes.  UGH!  But it was by far my favorite book out of the five.  Book three is my second favorite.  

     I will have to check out Greyfox.

  • Glad you enjoyed it. I love the sketches!!

  • Can hardly wait to read it!  My tenant has promised to loan me his copy …. as soon as his mother finishes w/ it, and maybe his father too!

  • I guess maybe i never thought of the HP books as childrens books.We had a lover(she was a wicca no less) three years back that used to read HP then give the books too her niece.That was the first i had heard of HP.Also if they were aimed at youth only why would larger citys have midnight book debutes?

    just getting around to catching up on all my SIR,will check out greyfox!

  • What a wonderful review! I too loved Tonks and got some good giggles from the Weasly twins….  Great writer that J.K. Rowlings. I believe that she writes Fiction that just happens to be suitable for a younger audience….

  • ::stands up::

    hello…my name is Lucky…and I haven’t read any of the Harry Potter books nor have I seen the movies…yet….

    ::sits down::

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *