August 15, 2009

  • Sharing

    As an only child, I didn’t have as much early experience or training in sharing as kids do who have siblings.  It wasn’t entirely lacking.  My parents didn’t neglect that aspect of my development.  The issue just didn’t come up often in my early years.  Taking turns and sharing were challenges I was compelled to meet in kindergarten. 

    I remember fighting over paints and being sent to sit in a chair facing a corner of the classroom, wearing the dunce cap.  It was the 1940s, and that was considered appropriate punishment.  But I digress….

    Later in my childhood, when it was just my mother and me, “share and share alike,” was one of her favorite aphorisms.  She preached it a lot, and practiced it where food was concerned, but not much otherwise.  I would get in big trouble for getting into her toiletries, cosmetics and “stuff,” and if there was conflict over what to watch on TV, etc., she had the power and wasn’t inclined to defer to me or take turns.

    The custom of equal divisions of food portions from my mother’s household did not survive in mine.  If one of us wants to have part of something set aside to eat later, he or she makes a point of saying so.  Otherwise, it’s common property and nobody gets any grief for eating more than a “fair share.”  Share and share alike would not work for Doug and me because our tastes are very different and his caloric requirement is greater than mine.  Our system works now that the household is just the two of us, because neither of us is greedy and we have plenty.

    I’m having new problems with sharing now, and I’m not sure that even growing up in a big family would have prepared me for this.  It is a different kind of sharing.  I have observed the meaning of “share” evolving through my lifetime.  I was in my thirties before I heard anyone say, “Thanks for sharing,” in reference to a personal revelation or amusing anecdote. 

    Now, social media have added new connotations to “sharing” just as they have to, “friend.”  The “friends” I have on Facebook are mostly strangers to me.  Although only a few of these people are really my friends, I’m going to omit the quotation marks for the sake of convenience.  I assume you know what I mean. 

    I have been seeing conflicts develop because some people think that their FB friends are sharing things that are inappropriate, or that they are sharing too much of one thing or another.  I ran into a bit of that sort of judgment on Xanga while I was writing my memoirs.  One tight-assed Xanga Relic commented that reading my memoirs was like walking in on me as I stepped from the shower.  That’s me, the naked autobiographer.  Read me at your own risk.

    I bridle at even the suggestion of censorship.  If my revelations are startling, annoying or offensive, nobody needs to be exposed to them more than once.  Anyone who subscribes to me here, or any friend who includes my input in his newsfeed on Facebook, has no room to complain about anything I “share.” 

    Facebook makes it even easier to hide the output of a friend than Xanga makes the process of blocking or unsubbing.  I have concluded that those who complain about what their friends share are either ignorant of the ease of hiding people and blocking apps, or they have control issues, are afraid of offending the friends who have offended them, or just get perverse pleasure from criticizing and complaining.

    I get many invitations, suggestions, and requests from Facebook friends that I choose, for one reason or another, not to accept.  I block and hide apps frequently.  Less frequently, I hide the entire feed from a friend.  Even less frequently than that, I unfriend someone.  If any of those actions angers or offends someone or hurts her feelings, that is her problem, not mine.  I’m exercising my admin-given prerogatives.  These social media are new enough that anybody’s idiosyncratic rules of conduct are bound to lack the force of tradition. 

    I tend to live by my own rules anyway.  I have a simple rule of thumb that helps me decide whether someone’s egregious behavior warrants having her feed hidden or being deleted as my friend.  It’s based on how I feel when I look at her profile pic.  It is entirely arbitrary and capricious, my business, not hers.  I don’t make a production of it, no threats to hide or delete her if she doesn’t shape up and do things my way.  It’s perfectly okay with me if everyone goes on doing things their own way, as long as I have control over my exposure to what they’re doing.

Comments (20)

  • I was NOT an only child.  We shared and we had our own.  What I find here on Xanga is my choice, my rules too.  We are all so individual in our perspectives of what the social rules should be, I can’t waste my time playing games.  I just know when I don’t want to see someones pulses or blog entries anymore.  I just know.  The friend thing is for keeping a “line out” for that person who wants to read me or me them.  I’ll bite and then consider as time goes by. Sometimes it’s very temporary.  Others have been solid gold connections. The people who I comment and they comment me, well… we have a different friendship.  Each one individual, but we get to know a bit more of each other every time we connect.  I enjoy your writing as you give me new perspectives everytime I read your posts.  Oh and one more thing…Thanks for sharing, Kathy.

  • good blog. I ‘m on facebook but most of the people I didn’t know so I deleted everyone except my best friends and I kept my relatives.

    I don’t really see what the fun is on facebook? I guess I’m missing something.

  • I really love reading your posts, not the least because I think you’re very skilled at analyzing reactions of people down to their core issues.  I do think some people just like to complain because it gives them some feeling of superiority.

    It’s not quite the same thing, but I’m reminded of when I started keeping an online journal, something over ten years ago.  At the time I was in an unhappy marriage but having an affair with a married man.  I was writing to sort out my feelings, to figure out root causes, etc., not trying to extol the virtues of the situation (of which there were not many).  I got an inordinate amount of judgment from drive-by commenters trying to tell me what to do and yes, that I was sharing too much.  My typical reaction at the time was “nobody’s putting a gun to your head to read this”, but alas, there wasn’t quite the same level of filtering sophistication available then (i.e. friends lock, etc.) as there is now.  I changed monikers more than once because of that issue.

    My Facebook friends are truly only people I have known in “real life” with few exceptions, but as such, my Facebook is very PG-13 because of the diversity of the audience (old high school classmates to current classmates to family members).  I much prefer my Xanga outlet for writing about my life.

  • @Jillycarmel - For me, most of the fun on FB is in Fairyland, My Zoo and Barn Buddy:  game apps.  I play a while, then I look at my newsfeed, I share links to news items or science stories, send positive affirmations or symbolic virtual gifts to my friends — and I have a network of FB friends that includes my favorite authors and musicians, my spiritual mentors, and a bunch of weirdos as strange as I am.

    @Tyche - I don’t write about my life on FB.  I play, read feed from Greenpeace, Der Spiegel, NPR, ACLU, comment on anything and everything….  When I have something to say that takes more than fifty words, I come back to Xanga.

  • oh, I see cause I just like to use it to keep up with family and friends and they I will have to look up those sites.

  • I think the reason most people are concerned about people sharing too much is that many employers are googling thier employees and getting offended about things they deem to not be appropriate….My problem with that is that while you might not agree with my opinion that does not effect my ability to be a good employee and what I do in my personal life is my personal business…not that I am really out there but at the same time if I choose in my private life to be a conservationist as long as it does not effect my job performance it should be no ones business but my own

  • I have to agree with the above commentor.  I’m not usually too private with what I write, but all the names concerning my work place and it’s goings on are aliases… to protect the innocent and not so, as the case may be.  I do know two Xangans who were fired from their jobs (at the same place) because of a “friend” who turned them in. 

  • very few people ever realized sarah was an only child.  she shared well.  it was that or have me take the object of non-share away. 

    still stubbornly refusing to do facebook. shoot, i don’t even write here much now.  ennui?  or just plain tired of me.  who knows.

    i’ve learned to not give away anything about my employer.  i can post phone calls but those are pretty generic to anyone who’s a customer service rep i think.  of course my employers spend more time watching facebook.  yet another reason to avoid it like the plague.

  • I’ve only had to unfriend 2 people on FB…  One because she took my email address from the page and submitted it for spamming with crap from her idiotic company.  (And I DO mean idiotic.  It was dog jewelry, ffs.  Puppy bling.  *EYEROLL*)

    The other one I dropped deleted one of my comments from one of her ignorant right wing posts.  Not that all things related to the right wing are ignorant, but this one was.  I don’t care if people with different views than my own post articles I disagree with, but if I make a non-abusive comment and they censor me?  Then I don’t feel the need to maintain that “friendship”.

    But I block irritating apps all the time. 

  • @fairydragonstar - 
    @warweasel - The conflict I observed on FB was not so much about anyone revealing anything inappropriate.  It was one person becoming upset that another was “cluttering” her newsfeed with trivial game-related posts that didn’t interest her.  Instead of simply hiding the game apps (something facebook makes very easy:  a click, a menu drops, click again and that app never shows on your page again unless you undo the “hide.”) some choose to complain, rant, threaten to hide or delete the “inconsiderate” clutterers, trying to change the others’ behavior instead of using the tools at their disposal to avoid the clutter.

    @lupa - I’m wondering if the right winger is the same one I unfriended.  I have seen my comments disappear, too.  Some people seem to consider all dissent, no matter how benign in tone, unacceptable.  On one of the political polls, I saw a comment complaining that when the poll started out, it was running three-to-one anti-Obama, and then the tide turned and it went 3-to-1 the other way.  The only explanation that fool could think of was that “left-wingers flooded” the poll.  It must have escaped him that at first the poll circulated among the originator’s friends, and then got into the general population.

    @Jillycarmel - You can search FB for names of people you’d like to hear from, such as authors or celebrities, or join pages for news outlets you like to keep up with, and their feed will show on your page.  If I had any idea what you like, I could suggest some friends for you.  I’m pretty sure you would enjoy the Fairyland game.  Millions of people do, and playing it saves rainforests, a few square feet at a time, but it adds up to square miles with all those people playing.

  • @SuSu - yeah on the apps unless I like to play…it gets blocked what I don;t like is the fact the employers care and think they can censor what they DEEM… not that it is or isn’t inaapropiate …an example would be stated I go to the bowling alley every Friday and drink…which I do in in the winter…that the act of drinking could be censored or if I am not left wing or right wing enough in politics…I tend to be middle of the road a little more right then left….or religion…that is what I don’t like or the very fact that I blog and I let it be public

  • @SuSu - I doubt it’s the same person.  The one I dropped was an old high school acquaintance who appears to live a somewhat sheltered life.  Her arguments for her side would irritate you pretty quickly, as they’re usually pretty ignorant and poorly thought out.  I haven’t heard of people bitching about polls like that, but your explanation for that incident makes a lot of sense.  

  • @SuSu - oh, I started to venture out and found the Fairyland you talked about. thanks

  • don’t do facebook, i get my newsfeeds from my isp homepage or my xanga right column.
    a manager from a previous employer found my xanga by chance and recommended i not mention equipment or products by name (after which we discussed more poignant aspects of significant rants).
    don’t do video games. the only one i ever spent any time on was ‘roadrage’, until i discovered that to advance beyond a certain level you MUST become aggressive/abusive against the competition.

    i wholly agree with the ‘too much sharing’ thing…if it harms none but offends you? look away.

  • Your admin-given prerogatives, eh?  You should write a song about it, like an update on the old Bobby Brown tune.  That’s funny!

    I rarely get that “too much sharing for me” sensation.  I think I am so interested in other people (and I’ve been so wayward in my own life) that few things shock me or make me wish I had turned away.  In fact, the only thing I’m really squeamish about is those shows that one of the cable channels keep running about people purposely getting tapeworms.  Anything involving worms actually. 

    I always think it’s really funny when people waste time getting offended about things, especially in this whole blog/social networking thing when, as you say, people are choosing to read certain things.  Nobody’s popping out of a bush and flashing anyone here.

    I grew up an only child, too, and my husband likes to point out that I have sharing problems because of it.  Maybe so, maybe not. In my mind, I like to point out that he has a problem with feeling like he’s always getting cheated because he was the adopted child.

    I just thought of something.  I saw that movie “Rachel Gets Married” yesterday.  It was lovely!  In fact, I watched it two times in a row.  But there was a song featured in that movie, “Unknown Legend”?  Do you know it!  Reminds me a little bit of um,,,you??  (:

  • @quitchick - I don’t think I’ve ever heard the song, “Unknown Legend,” but it sounds like something I wouldn’t mind being.  I had a few legendary adventures in my youth.

    Like you, I’m so interested in people’s thoughts, feelings, and experiences, and the details — DETAILS — that nothing authentic that anyone shares grosses me out or turns me off.  My mind tends to wander when the discourse is very general or theoretical — or fantastical.  I crave reality.  If I watched TV, I know I’d be addicted to reality shows.

  • I was not an only child but I sure lived like one in fact I lived like I was a child of the wild…if you look close enough at my FB you will see why…hugs systa

  • Replica
    watches
    are very popular for the
    people, you can buy cheap and high quality replica Rolex watches from replica
    watches UK

    online store. Replica watches store provides all kinds of famous brand
    watches, such as replica tag watches, replica omega watches and Swiss
    watches
    .
    Happy shopping fromreplica
    watches UK
    online
    for sale at
    http://www.ireplicawatchesuk.com/.

  • Replica
    watches
    are very popular for the
    people, you can buy cheap and high quality replica Rolex watches from replica
    watches UK

    online store. Replica watches store provides all kinds of famous brand
    watches, such as replica tag watches, replica omega watches and Swiss
    watches
    .
    Happy shopping fromreplica
    watches UK
    online
    for sale at
    http://www.ireplicawatchesuk.com/.

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *