March 23, 2008

  • I don’t remember.

    Occasionally, when I post memoirs, someone remarks on how good my memory is.  This always causes me to wonder if there are really people who get through life with more defective memories than mine.  My forgetter works much more efficiently than my rememberer, but sometimes not as well as I’d like.  I have spontaneous and almost photographic recall of certain scenes and events, most of them either traumatic, dramatic or somehow especially memorable.  Other things, such as phone numbers, names, dates, and the like, I can recall with some effort if I can associate them with something else.

    If I add up the elapsed times for all the little mind movies that I can recall, however, they make up only a very small portion of my lifetime.  Most of what I did or saw, for all my hours and days, is just a blank.  What came first and which event followed what, I can usually only deduce if I recall where something happened and when I was in that place.  Thus, for example, the memories of events occurring in the fifteen years I lived at Elvenhurst, our old place across the highway from here, are a jumble without coherent chronology.  Fortunately, that was the longest time I ever stayed in one place.  Moving around a lot has certainly enhanced my memory.

    Having forgotten so much can be maddening when one is trying to write a memoir.  It seems inappropriate to write a memoir that focuses primarily on what I don’t remember.

    I don’t remember everything that my first husband, “Ford”, said to me on the phone that Thanksgiving night in 1960.  He said he loved me.  He said he was sorry.  He said he wanted me back.  I told him I wouldn’t go back.  I know we talked longer than that.  I suppose, based on things I remember his having said at other times in similar circumstances, that he blamed his brutality on alcohol, swore that it would never happen again, and said that I had been in the wrong, too.

    He said he missed Marie, and invoked the responsibilities and privileges of fatherhood.  I must have commented on how he had abused her and the way he complained about her crying and the expense of feeding and providing for her.  I can’t imagine letting him slip those statements by me without comment.

    He probably ran the old lines about how we belonged together, and everyone said we wouldn’t make it, so we had to stay together to show them.  I don’t remember.  I guess he must have said that since I wouldn’t come back to him, he would come to me.  I don’t remember it being said, but that was what happened.

    I don’t know how long it was after that conversation before he showed up.  I don’t recall how he got there, how long he stayed, or how he was traveling when he left.  He might have had a car, or hitchhiked, or ridden on a bus or train.  I don’t know.  If it was bus or train, I don’t know how he paid for it.

    I know that he didn’t like life on the ranch and was unenthusiastic about helping with the work.  He hated getting mud on his shoes, and refused to get shit on them.  Blood or shit on his hands was out of the question.  He didn’t want to get within biting range of the rabbits or cows, but he would go up in the hay loft and throw down bales for someone else to break up and distribute.  The idea of his trying to learn to milk a cow is absurd.  He was willing to drive the tractor, but not skilled enough at it to be permitted to do anything useful.

    I don’t recall who had given me the puppy that Marie called hers, how long we had him, or what we named him.  I remember that Ford killed that puppy.  Grady saw him do it, but Ford denied it.  I knew he was lying.  In the aftermath of that incident, Ford left to go north to Stockton, where he had an aunt or a cousin or something.

    I don’t know how long after that it was before he called me up and said that he had a job and had rented an apartment in Lodi for us.  I can deduce that it was about a month or month and a half, because I recall something that happened on 21 January, 1961, and I had been in Lodi for at least a week or two by then.  I don’t know how he talked me into going there, but I suppose my mother was partially instrumental in my decision to go, just as she had been a major part of my reason for wanting to get married and out of her house in the first place.

    I remember that Marie and I rode a bus from Redlands to Lodi.  I remember seeing Christmas decorations, but don’t recall whether we spent Christmas at the ranch or in Lodi.  What came next, I remember with too much clarity for comfort.

Comments (12)

  • I have had a strange memory day as well… I was thinking of writing about it, but don’t know if I could share as openly as you have.

    Hugs, Tricia

  • Yes, a strange day for remembering.  I have huge parts of my life, particularly my first marriage, that I remember nothing about, having blocked most of it as a way to survive.  Unfortunately, it also means that I also don’t remember some of the very good parts of it either, which is sad.

    Namaste!  Love your stories, are you planning a book when you are done?

    Hugs!

  • @lacemagicke - 

    Yes, I plan to make my memoirs into a book or a series.  I need an editor, and a publisher.

  • Peculiar that your Mother would be cautious about rabbit food around Marie but not an boy-man that beat women and killed puppies.  I’ve never gotten a lot of advice over the years; at least not directly.  After choices have been made a few loved ones have said, “I was worried that would happen” or “I wanted to tell you..” but they never did. I get the feeling that people have always been afraid to give their opinions to me.  As I read your memoirs I tend to believe that people have always approached you in the same way.   I think you have a beautiful literary knack for painting pictures with your words and that’s what makes your memoirs so good.  Don’t question your memory so much as just getting it out.  Worry about accuracy when it’s all said and done.  Did I just give you advice?  We’ll see how that works out for us. 

  • @fatgirlpink - 

    “Don’t question your memory so much as just getting it out.”

    I thought that was what I did here.  “I don’t remember,” was my title, and the repetition throughout was a literary device.

  • @SuSu - you did. 

  • There is so much I don’t remember and although some things are probably best left unremembered, at times I think that the only way to purge them would be to remember and then get on with it.

  • I think all of us have memories that work like this, stronger on the points of drama/trauma.  reading your blog in counterpoint to your memoir is a fascinating exercise – like constantly flipping to the end of the book to make sure your favorite characters survived. 

  • I can’t imagine a mom fussing over rabbit pellets but “allowing” a daughter to go back to an abusive fuckwit like Ford, either.  *headdesk*

  • Did I miss the end of the Family dinner event?  I wish I could remember more events in my past but oh well.

  • …strangely enough, i have an aunt (and a few cousins) that either live or grew up in lodi..

  • RYC: on Grey walker’s site; you’re not so much older than me, and your life with your first husband sounds so much like mine. I was 16 when I married and spent the next 8 years living in fear of his rage and anger. I often wondered if me and my sons would wake up dead some morning. Kudos to you for surviving and being able to write about it!

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *