January 30, 2006
-
How I Feel About My Feelings
Several factors determine the extent of a person’s control over how she feels. Feelings themselves don’t originate from a single source. If people can’t agree on a single definition for just one emotion such as “love”, then it is obvious that we are going to have difficulty agreeing on a definition of “emotion.” Having read widely in the fields of psychology, metaphysics, semantics and semiotic, I have encountered many definitions for emotion and feeling.
My favorite authors are those who begin by defining their terms. One such is E. J. Gold, in whose lexicon there is only one true “emotion” (Love, of the spiritual kind), and the other things we generally call emotions are, to him, actually thoughts or feelings. Possibly because I’m female, I am not going to try setting up arbitrary definitions, but will be using words such as “feeling” and “emotion” interchangeably because that is how it is done in common usage.
First, I will dispense with Love (the spiritual kind), because it is, I feel, a special case and easiest to eliminate from the discussion. This is the one that doesn’t just happen to us. We don’t fall into it, although we might grow into it. It is not an object we can obtain from others through manipulation or exchange for Love or anything else, even though experiencing this unconditional spiritual love from someone else has the power to kindle such feelings in oneself if one is open to that. It is a choice we can make, an action we can take, a Universal force to which we can attune ourselves. It is energy, and can be employed to heal anger, hatred, insecurity and all the other fear-based emotions. It is entirely within our control to decide whether to live in this Love or not.
The other “love” (and I’m not going to deal with “love” of pizza, Maserati, movies, the color purple or San Francisco, which everyone understands refers to fondness or preference), the “romantic” kind that sweeps over us and takes our breath away, making it impossible for us to perceive any human flaws in its object or to be contented when we are out of the object’s immediate presence… well, that’s very different. It comprises (or can include) passion, intimacy, bonded attachment, and a decision to commit to a partner.
In Why We Love, Dr. Helen Fisher examines and explains the origins of these feelings in the caudate nucleus of the mammalian brain and the way they naturally evolve from passionate lust to affectionate attachment over time through the mediation of neuroelectrochemistry. At last, from her research and that of her colleagues, the processes of falling in and out of love make sense. Astute and aware individuals have always recognized that these feelings are inextricably bound up with the biological urge to procreate, but along the way culture has confused the issue with euphemistic circumlocutions and hypocritical myths that have been perpetuated in fictional romances, fairy tales and soap opera.
Since those feelings originate in brain chemistry (electrochemistry, actually, but lets keep it oversimplified, okay?), we could, if we wished, “control” them with drugs. Many people do alter their emotions chemically, either intentionally or unintentionally. So, there is part of my answer: yes, we can “control” our feelings by altering our brain chemistry with drugs. Some of the problems inherent in that method include toxic effects of the drugs and unwanted “feelings” that result from imprudent and/or uninformed choices of the drugs one uses.
A simpler way to “control” feelings is to change the way we think about how we feel. Anyone who has ever gotten over the “heartbreak” of being dumped by a lover, or who has forced oneself not to become involved with an inappropriate but very attractive partner, has used this method. The dynamics of neuroelectrochemistry appear to be a complex feedback loop in which thoughts control feelings and feelings control thoughts and we have some degree of control over which forces predominate.
As long as we deny responsibility for our feelings, they will be out of our control. If we believe, for example, that someone can hurt our feelings, our feelings are going to be hurt a lot because people in general will not always say and do the things we want them to. If our self-esteem is contingent on the esteem and approval we receive from others, then those others will control our feelings.
Once we take responsibility for our own feelings and realize that we have the power to choose not to be hurt by the thoughts, feelings and actions of others, we will no longer be hurt by others. It really is that simple. I know that because I have gone from being a high-strung, over-sensitive, clingy, emotionally needy crybaby always seeking approval and external validation, to being a sensitive, secure, loving and emotionally independent person, through taking responsibility for my own feelings.
Note that I said “through” taking responsibility and not “by” that. Subtle semantic difference, it means that the process started with that decision, but the choice and commitment were not all there was to the process. Over time, my habits of thought and feeling changed. At first, if someone rejected me or abused me or slandered me, I’d react negatively and then I’d remind myself of this: “What others think of me is none of my business.”
If everyone had turned against me at once, I might not have been able so easily to deal with it, but that is very unlikely to happen to anyone. Dr. Seuss said it best: “Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don’t matter and those who matter don’t mind.”
I weaned myself from that need for external validation at the same time that I was building independent self-esteem. In the same way that it helped to remember that other people’s thoughts and feelings are none of my business, I was aided by this injunction: “Do nothing to damage your self-esteem.” If I screwed up and did something of which I disapproved, I did what I could to clean up the mess, reminded myself that everyone is fallible, treated the whole thing as a learning experience and resolved not to make the same mistake again. By that process, my self-esteem grew and my need for external validation dwindled away.
Over time, there has been less and less sting from things people say and do to me. When something does trigger a knee-jerk response from me, I am less likely than I used to be to fall into hurt feelings or fly into a rage, so I am able to respond more sensibly and appropriately. It works not only with those “feelings” that can get “hurt” by rejection and disapproval. It also works with more obvious and overt fear reactions. It’s all fear, after all. Hurt feelings are only the manifestation of the fear of inadequacy, isolation, rejection, etc.
I may never entirely lose that knee-jerk “emotional” response. I see an analogy between that and the physical startle response to loud noises, unexpected touches or similar sudden shocks. I recall a time when, if someone startled me, I would say, “You scared me.” I don’t say that any more, nor do I think it. If my body jerks and starts at a surprising event, I know I’m startled. It barely deserves a thought most of the time. That understanding of the startle response, and my having lost the more-or-less automatic association of startlement with fear, allows me to more effectively respond when I’m startled by something that requires quick response.
Knowing that I am responsible for my own feelings also liberates me from responsiblity for other people’s feelings. Nobody can lay a guilt trip on me if I say or do something that “hurts her feelings,” as long as her hurt feelings were not my objective but only an incidental result of her taking offense at my frankness. I know that it is her choice to be hurt, that her decision to take offense is a sign of her own emotional irresponsibility and low self-esteem, and that I have a responsiblity to myself and the universe to express my own thoughts and feelings openly and honestly regardless of any anticipated response they might trigger in someone else. The handy aphorism that reminds me of reality in this instance is, “It is equally spiritually unevolved to take offense as it is purposely to give it.”
The Emotional Self-Control Tool Kit
I must not fear
Fear is the mind-killer.
Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration.
I will face my fear.
I will permit it to pass
Over me and through me.
And when it has gone past
I will turn the inner eye
To see its path.
Where the fear has gone
There will be nothing.
Only I will remain….from Dune
by Frank Herbert
“Be who you are and say what you feel,
because those who mind don’t matter
and those who matter don’t mind.”
Theodore Seuss Geisel
It is equally spiritually unevolved to take offense
as purposely to give it.What others think of me is none of my business.
Do nothing to damage your self-esteem.
Comments (20)
Thanks Kathy that was awesome! I think when I realized LOML was bipolar and it wasn’t that he didn’t meet my expectations it was that i needed to choose… choose to be with him because I wanted to not out of obligation, guilt, financial need etc ~ both are families are pretty disfunctional and negative; it makes me laugh to think about it. I raised my kids to know no one could hurt their feelings they had to choose to get them be hurt.
I have been learning so much about myself and really realizing that if tomorrow all my worldy posessions were taken …SO WHAT; i’d get a job slinging beer and find a place to squat. Elsa told me that I was in a neptune transit conjunct sun and it would rock my world — and your reading showed so much of it too; but i could hever have guessed life would start to become so simple and clear.
I too still have knee jerk reactions but the response is up to me RESPONSE~ABILITY
I love the Dr Suess quote — I may use it in my banner for a while
I like your view on many things because it is unvarnished…
just so, so excellent. i have the dr. seuss quote on my xanga already! someone told me the one about “what others think of me is none of my business” and it took me a long time to really, really understand and accept it.
I’m so sure I choose my feelings, or choose how I let my feelings affect me. Getting caught in those semantic traps already. When I hear someone say “I can’t help it that’s just how I feel” I roar inside “oh, but you can“, however it is a very unpopular viewpoint and one I’ve learned to keep to myself. I’ll be back to reread this in more depth from home, I should learn to stay away from here when I’m at work!
Two things–one, to muddy the semantic water still more, there are those who preface an opinion by saying “I feel that. . . “ They MEAN “I think that. . .”–evidently they are afraid of being thought to be thoughtful
Two, there is the RET thing that says we can control our feelings by how we think about things. That, however, begs the question of whether we can control our thoughts–most unevolved souls cannot.
PS–see my private site for a message–not important, really, just private.
I can understand this on so many levels. Great post, as always.
Excellent post, you make a number of very good points. I did however, start to take issue with your final point:
Nobody can lay a guilt trip on me if I say or do something that “hurts her feelings,” as long as her hurt feelings were not my objective but only an incidental result of her taking offense at my frankness. I know that it is her choice to be hurt, that her decision to take offense is a sign of her own emotional irresponsibility and low self-esteem, and that I have a responsiblity to myself and the universe to express my own thoughts and feelings openly and honestly regardless of any anticipated response they might trigger in someone else.
Yes, it is your right and responsibility (and mine) to express your own thoughts, etc., but as a more “emotionally educated/refined/whatever” person, shouldn’t you (or I, or whomever as such) attempt to be more aware of/sensitive to the emotional deficiences of others? No matter how self-aware and confident one is, I still think that it is a wise move and a sign of emotional maturity to think before speaking in consideration of others.
Abdication of responsibility for emotion is a huge business. There are loads of psychologists who treat individuals. Sometimes I think that “therapy” actually reinforces this abdication.
Cool!
I was liking all those quotes so much that I was going to copy each one and transfer them to my site and then I get to the end and find them all neatly packaged for me!
I really like this post and am going to link to it. I think this is the most beneficial thing that I am learning from you.
Talk to you soon!
Angie
Your post hit home for me on so many levels, and one of them is that taking responsibility for one’s emotions is something my hubby has preached at me for a while…and I think he (and you!) are correct. I’ve gone through therapy for so many year’s, but one thing that I was never really taught (and probably to keep therapists in business) is that one has to take this level of responsibility for one’s own feelings, just like one’s actions. I simply adore the Dr. Seuss quote, and only within the past year had I heard of Frank Herbert’s Dune series
.
I was hoping I could also link this info. on my xanga…I think a lot of people would benefit from it, because I know I have!!!
Blessings,
Erin
I lost my damn comment again.
“If our self-esteem is contingent on the esteem and approval we receive from others, then those others will control our feelings….Once we take responsibility for our own feelings and realize that we have the power to choose not to be hurt by the thoughts, feelings and actions of others, we will no longer be hurt by others.”
This is the part that really struck me. It relates most closely to my relationship (and current disintegration thereof) with the friend I blogged about. I have always let her opinion of me rule how I feel about myself, and it’s that very problem that has had me dwelling on the whole situation for days now. I’m upset because I think she thinks badly of me. But it shouldn’t matter. I’m going to have to work on it, but soon I hope it won’t matter. Thanks for directing me here; it was a great help.
Recovery!
I’m quite familiar with this. I know it’s one of my biggest weaknesses. I’d been working on this to some degree of success in the last year. I’m not sure what’s changed, or why I can’t seem to control my feelings now.
I haven’t been mediating or doing yoga much in the last month, both of which seem to help a lot. Perhaps that’s what I need to do.
I sure need to do something.
Thanks Kathy
Wow, it’s comforting to find so many people struggle with the same internal issues I do. Yay I feel less alone.
@hipchick525600 - Always think before you speak, but if you choose to alter what you were going to say, do so to make it more clear and accurate, not for any considerations of how another person might choose to react.
@KaiOaty – Why bother to respond to a comment that was posted over three years ago? In fact, I believe you DID respond to my comment already, three years ago, via a private message from your alter-xanga ego.
At any rate, as it was over three years ago, and as people change I have grown and I have learned more, and I think that I have a better understanding of what SuSu (ahem) was trying to say here and I think that I agree with her now, even if I didn’t three years ago. While I do choose to practice this internally and to not take offense/get hurt by what others may say, in a world where people do not take responsibility for their own feelings and “political correctness” is compulsory, it is difficult to practice what she preaches; because of that I find that I still have to monitor myself in case I might hurt someone’s feelings, lest I create a “hostile work environment”. And I will always be sensitive to the feelings of those that I love, regardless.
@hipchick525600 - The original comment predated Xanga’s “reply” feature, and I thought it deserved a public response since people still read this post.
Now, since reading your reply to the reply, I think the issue deserves a new blog. Thanks for the inspiration.
ryc: very true. i’m not that concerned. i just find it interesting when that happens, so i described the most recent example. satire, you know. i’m ok with it. =)
“If our self-esteem is contingent on the esteem and
approval we receive from others, then those others will control our
feelings.”
that’s perfect. i used to operate this way… but not for a long time. whew.
@TheBigShowAtUD - One of my handicaps is a literal-minded inability to recognize satire unless it is as absurdly extreme as Monty Python.
And we guarantee all of Replica Bags are high quality same with the originals, and we offer the reasonable price for you.This Replica Bag are crafted in Damier canvas with natural cowhide trimmings and fashioned in golden metallic hardware.