October 30, 2005

  • body part pie

    gluten-free, sugar-free, no-cow’s-milk

    Body Part Pie



    I was not prepared to wait until after
    halloween for the traditional jack o’lantern pie, so as I was carving
    Winky Jack today, I carefully saved what I cut out of his generous
    mouth, his one big sorta-roundish eye, the other more-or-less winky
    eye, and both of the nostrils that turned out perhaps bigger than
    nostrils should be — heck, I wanted enough punkin body parts for pie,
    didn’t I? 

    As he turned
    out, if you use
    your imagination, either he has little beady eyes and a mismatched pair
    of ears, or he’s got a wink and a wide-open nose.  He isn’t
    pretty, but he’s pretty scary, which is traditionally what jack
    o’lanterns are spozed to be, eh?  Besides, the Body Part Pie
    recipe won’t work with one of those fine-lined, pretty, artistic
    new-fangled pumpkin carvings — not enough bulk to the dismembered bits.

    After I microwaved Jack’s dismembered body parts in a covered bowl for
    ten minutes and removed the rind, I mashed them with a potato
    masher.  They could also be pureed in a blender or hacked up in a
    food processor.  I like my pumpkin pie sorta lumpy.  After
    the cooking and mashing was done, I determined that I had 2 cups of
    pumpkin, enough for one pie.

    I made more than enough pastry for one crust, for two reasons:  I
    like a generous fluted edge on my crust so the pie won’t boil over, and
    working with gluten-free flours, it is difficult to roll pastry thin
    without tearing it.  Excuse me a moment, I’m starting to salivate here.  I’m gonna go and get another slice of coffee and a cup of fresh pie.

    Mmmmmm.  That’s what I said when I tasted that first slice while
    it was still a little warm, and I’ll say it again, but don’t let Doug
    hear me.  When I realized my error the first time, I corrected
    myself quickly, said, “I mean, yuuukk!  That’s awful pie. 
    I’m sure you don’t want any of it.”    Since Doug had
    his first slice of it, we have both been assuring each other that it is
    indeed really nasty pie and we will each sacrifice him/herself to save
    the other from having to eat it.  It’s over half gone, now.

    PREHEAT OVEN TO 425 degrees Fahrenheit.

    Pastry Recipe:

    Whisk together:

    2 cups garbanzo and fava bean flour (mine comes as a pre-mixed combo from http://www.bobsredmill.com.)
    1 teaspoon salt
    1 teaspoon xanthan gum (takes the place of gluten to hold the pastry together)


    Cut into flour mixture with pastry blender or two knives, or mash into it with a fork:

    1 1/3 cups chilled butter


    When the largest bits of butter are pea-sized or smaller, mix in with a fork:

    1/2 cup cold water


    This, of course, is rolled flat on a floured surface and gently fit into a pie pan, with the edge turned up and fluted.

    This made more pastry than I needed for the pie, so I rolled the excess
    dough flat, cut it into little rounds with a cookie cutter, brushed the
    tops with a glaze made from Splenda and goat milk, baked them about ten
    minutes at 425 degrees F, and we had some weird bean cookies while we
    waited for the pie to bake and cool.

    Filling Recipe:

    Lightly beat:

    two eggs


    Add to eggs, mixing after each addition:

    2 cups cooked and mashed pumpkin body parts
    1 1/2 cups goat milk (I used an undiluted can of evaporated goat milk for extra creaminess)
    1 cup granular Splenda (the kind that measures cup-for-cup like sugar)
    1/2 teaspoon salt
    1 1/2 teaspoons cinnamon
    1 teaspoon ground ginger

    (optionally,
    you can also add 1/2 teaspoon ground cloves if you like cloves, or you
    can substitute 2 or 3 teaspoons of Chinese five spice for the other
    spices, if you prefer)

    Pour the filling mixture into the unbaked pie shell and bake in the
    preheated 425-degree oven for 15 minutes.  Lower oven temperature
    to 350 degrees – LEAVE THE PIE IN THERE! – and bake for another 45
    minutes.  When done, a clean knife inserted in the center should
    come out clean.

    Tell everyone that body part pie with bean crust is nasty stuff, and
    keep it all for yourself — do NOT foolishly go “Mmmmm…” over your
    first bite of it, as I did, or you will have to share.



Comments (10)

  • Hello SuSu,

    That pie looks beautiful. You made the crust just right it is really a pretty pie and it sounds really good. Your pumpkin does look scarey, good , as you said, they are supposed too!
    I may try this recipe. thanks for posting it here.

    RYC: True many people are not tuned in to each other or know whats right for every child. I am glad your Son has a mind of his own. Thanks for sropping by.. Buddha , wise words. Thank you.Take Care

    Peace and Love:)

  • I gotta tell ya…. A dish made from Winky Jack’s innards is right up there with pornish hens….

    ewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww……………

    Kidding…. Am sure it’s yummers…………

  • Thanks for your comment on my site and for sharing your recipe. Your pie looks delicious and Jack is great = very appropriately evil looking!

    I am reminded of a lemon meringue pie that I made some years ago. I had one piece and my husband had one piece. We went out for a little while and while we were gone, our son came home. When we got back, the pie was gone. Our son swore he only had one piece. Turns out he really did have one piece – he took a fork and ate 2/3 of a pie right out of the pie plate – all in one piece!

  • Yum. No Bob’s Red Mill delivery here (or at least I can’t afford it). So I make nutmeal crust and use almond or rice milk (with less water added) instead. Pumpkin is also rare in Sweden; there were none to be had last year but this year I got a HUGE 10 kilo one! Enough to freeze for mid-winter pies!

  • hmmm if I had some more time….maybe I can get my daughter to not only carve the pumkin but cook its body parts….thanks for the how to ( I can never remember how to spell that word for how to cook somrthing ) though I do knoow it..res sip pee..yeop if we lived in a phonetic world I would prosper

  • yum! That looks so good – I think I’ll pick up a few pumpkins even though we won’t be carving…
    I’ve been looking for those flours. I can get almost anything if I look hard enough, but no one has that mix & while I found garbanzo, I can’t find fava. I’m hoping the flour is the magic otherwise I’d have to say I’m hopeless at baking non-gluten. I have thrown out more than I’ve eaten ( I can’t afford to do that). All I can say is thank goodness for the few pre-mix packages I’ve found & frozen goodies, or Jacquie wouldn’t have much to eat!  

  • Pumpkin pie isn’t even one of my top favorites, but that pie looks positively delicious!!!!!

  • Nice looking fertility symbols.  :)

  • Sounds yummy and I collected the recipe.  Thank you very much.

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *